10 Delicious Places to Eat in Two Rivers, Wisconsin
Come Hungry. Leave Happy.
Whether you're here to stroll along Lake Michigan, bike the Mariners Trail, or just soak in some small-town charm, one thing’s for sure—you gotta eat. Luckily, Two Rivers, Wisconsin, may be small, but it packs a mighty punch when it comes to good eats.
From fish fries to fresh-baked pies, here are 10 must-try places to eat in Two Rivers—in no particular order, because honestly, they’re all worth a bite (or ten).
1. The Waverly Inn Pub & Pizzeria
📍1402 16th St
If you’re craving pizza, this is your spot. Their crispy crust, savory sauce, and Wisconsin cheese magic make for a pie that hits all the right notes. Bonus: the atmosphere is cozy and full of charm.
2. Two Rivers Family Restaurant
📍3015 Tannery Rd
A classic hometown diner renowned for its delicious home-cooked meals and excellent service. The restaurant offers an extensive breakfast menu, featuring a variety of omelets, pancakes, waffles, and skillets. Patrons have praised their French toasts, pancakes, and egg waffles. The establishment is family-oriented, providing a welcoming atmosphere for all guests
3. Rita's Supper Club (Formerly known as Machut's Supper Club)
📍3911 Lincoln Avenue
The supper club features a large salad bar, steak, stir-fry, and a wide selection of desserts and so much more!
4. Water’s Edge Restaurant
📍4514 Lakeview Dr (inside Lighthouse Inn)
Come for the view, stay for the lake perch. This lakefront gem offers stunning views of Lake Michigan and a solid mix of surf and turf. Perfect for a date night or a sunset dinner.
5. Cool City Brewery
📍1718 West Park Street
Cool City Brewing Company is renowned for its innovative food flights, allowing guests to sample a variety of flavors in one sitting. Among their popular offerings are slider flights, featuring an assortment of mini sandwiches that cater to diverse palates. This concept extends to other menu items as well, including the best Brussel sprout appetizer! And after dinner drinks- grasshoppers yum!
6. Susie-Q Fish Company- Grab and go!
📍1810 East Street
A must if you're a seafood lover visiting Two Rivers, Wisconsin. This family-owned market has been a local institution for over six generations. They specialize in smoked fish, prepared using traditional methods with sweet hard maple wood in their six smokehouses. Their offerings include salmon, lake trout, bluefin herring, smoked carp, smoked chubs, and whitefish, among others.
7. Casa Mexico
📍2022 Washington St
Craving tacos? Burritos? Fajitas the size of your head? Casa Mexico is fast, flavorful, and always satisfying. The chips and salsa alone are worth the visit. Not to mention those margaritas!
8. Connie’s Diner- cash only
📍1623 Washington St
It’s like stepping back in time—in the best way possible. Classic diner fare with friendly service and hearty breakfasts. If you leave hungry, that’s on you.
9. Port Sandy Bay
📍6421 County Rd O
Their pizza is legendary (try the cheeseburger pizza — trust us!), and the attached arcade is packed with games for the kids.
10. City central bar and grill
📍2014 Washington St
Our kids can’t get enough of their cheeseburgers – absolutely delicious!
Family-owned and always a joy to visit – such friendly faces every time!
11. Kurtz’s Pub & Deli
📍1410 Washington St
A local institution since 1904, Kurtz’s is the place for homemade soups, classic sandwiches, and a killer Reuben. Pair it with a cold beer and soak in the old-world German pub vibes.
Hungry Yet?
Two Rivers may be known for its lake views, outdoor adventures, and small-town charm—but don’t sleep on the food scene. Whether you’re in the mood for casual comfort or a sit-down dinner with a view, Two Rivers has something to satisfy every craving.
Eat like a local. Explore like a tourist. And don’t forget dessert.
-Visit Two Rivers- The Baeten Family